Best Practices Construction Law

Best Practices Construction Law

Best Practices Resources

Matt has written articles and given presentations on all aspects of construction law. Find a resource here.

Top Posts

Best Practices top posts include claims preparation, contract drafting, and litigation pitfalls. You don’t want to miss these ones.

Matthew DeVries

Matt is a construction & litigation attorney with Stites & Harbison, PLLC and father of seven young kids.

Category Archives: Case Law

Subscribe to Case Law RSS Feed

Differing Site Conditions and Why You Should Read Pages 17-20 of the Metcalf Decision

Posted in Best Practices, Case Law, Federal Construction, Legal Trends
It’s Friday morning and there are probably better things you would like to do with your remaining day than read a 22-page government contracts decision. But if you have ever experienced a differing site condition on your project, then here is why you should read pages 17-20 of the recent decision in Metcalf Construction Company … Continue Reading

Don’t Settle Your Construction Dispute Without Checking with the (Insurance) Man

Posted in Best Practices, Case Law, Legal Trends
Who’s the Man?  Ever heard of that phrase?  Well, in a recent construction dispute in Maryland, “the Man” was the owner’s insurance company.  And the lesson learned was: don’t settle your construction dispute without first checking with the man! In Perini/Tompkins Joint Venture v. ACE American Insurance Company (pdf), applying Maryland and Tennessee law, the … Continue Reading

A Fine Line: What the Law Says about Contractor Delays to Subcontractor Work

Posted in Case Law
As a general proposition, if the owner delays the prime contractor by not performing its contractual obligations, the prime contractor is entitled to relief, including damages for delay or extensions of time. This is actually a rather common situation and most contracts contain clauses and provisions that govern such occasions. But what happens when the … Continue Reading

Are Electronic Toll Collection Systems Subject to Competitive Bidding?

Posted in Case Law, Federal Construction, Tennessee, Transportation, VA, DC, MD
I was working in our Virginia office this past week and was amazed at the amount of highway construction at and around Tyson’s Corner.  What also caught my attention was the progress of the 495 Express Lanes project, which includes the construction of high occupancy toll (HOT) lanes that will operate on the I-495/Capital Beltway. … Continue Reading

2011 Construction Law Update Is Available

Posted in Case Law
One of the largest groups for construction lawyers is the American Bar Association’s Forum on the Construction Industry.  In the weeks leading up to to the Forum’s 2012 annual meeting in Las Vegas, Nevada last month, a number of construction attorneys and I were feverishly reviewing submissions for Division 10′s annual Construction Law Update.  The document is a … Continue Reading

Does a Construction Manager Have a Legal Duty for Site Safety?

Posted in Case Law
Today’s guest post is written by Joe Hardesty, who handles complex litigation in construction and business disputes. He has defended and prosecuted claims for clients arising from major construction projects throughout the country, surety disputes, commercial real estate disputes and a variety of disputes arising from business transactions. He also advises clients on matters related … Continue Reading

The Supremes Side with Road Builders in Clean Water Act Case

Posted in Case Law, Transportation
I had an admiralty professor at law school who would often refer to the Justices of the Supreme Court of the United States as ... get this ... the Supremes! In honor of Professor Jones, today's post is about the Supremes decision in PPL Montana, LLC v. Montana, where the court declined to expand the definition of "navigable" under federal law… Continue Reading

End of the Road for One Highway Contractor’s Claim

Posted in Case Law, Federal Construction, Tennessee, Transportation
Words matter. Yesterday, the Supreme Court of Tennessee released its decision in a construction dispute between Ray Bell Construction Company and the Tennessee Department of Transportation.  Where the contractor won the first two rounds at the trial court and intermediate appellate court levels, TDOT prevailed in the final appeal. The Dispute.  The primary issue in … Continue Reading

Ghostly Voice: “Tennessee Supreme Court Addresses Non-Delegable Duties to Subcontractors”

Posted in Case Law, Tennessee
Happy Halloween!  Today’s post is not about ghosts, ghouls and goblins, though.  It’s much scarier … it’s about contractors, subcontractors and insurance companies! (….shriek….) In a noteworthy decision issued last week, the Tennessee Supreme Court held that all construction contracts have an implied duty on part of the contractor to perform in a "careful, skillful, … Continue Reading

Who Can Help Interpret a Construction Contract: No One? The Contract? The Industry?

Posted in Case Law, Contract Docs
Last week, the Supreme Court of Tennessee heard oral arguments on a contract interpretation issue in a construction dispute between Ray Bell Construction and Tennessee Department of Transportation.  You can get the details here, but the real lesson is one about how to interpret contracts, whether you are talking about the scope of work, changes, compensation … Continue Reading

What Happens When Parties Are “Unclear” in Their Construction Contracts?

Posted in Case Law, Federal Construction
Last week I wrote a post about what is considered timely acceptance of a subcontractor’s quote. My friend and former colleague, Brian Waagner, submitted a comment to that post, focusing on the importance of a written contract.  Brian also blogs at The Contractor’s Perspective.  Brian’s comments are on-point, so I have included them here as … Continue Reading

Kentucky Supreme Court Adopts the Economic Loss Doctrine

Posted in Case Law, Georgia, Kentucky
Owners, contractors, and subcontractors in Kentucky should carefully review their legal claims given a recent Kentucky Supreme Court decision.  On June 16, 2011, the Court joined the majority of other states and adopted what is commonly know as the economic loss doctrine.  Now, claims against  suppliers for product defects are legally limited to the parties’ contract … Continue Reading

Floods and Heavy Rains: How to Best Prepare a Delay Claim for Unusually Severe Weather

Posted in Case Law, Federal Construction, Scheduling, Transportation
Yesterday, highway and bridge contractors in Tennessee received an alert from from TDOT officials about the affect of heavy rain in the area: "I’m sure most are aware of the anticipated rise in the Mississippi River, but could you please share with all that are working in the Mississippi River area and the backwater areas of … Continue Reading

Check Out the 2011 Construction Law Update for Construction Cases and Statutes

Posted in Case Law, Legal Trends, Legislation
In the weeks leading up to the ABA Forum on the Construction Industry’s annual meeting in Scottsdale, Arizona, a number of construction attorneys and I were feverishly reviewing submissions for this year’s Construction Law Update.  The document is a compilation of cases and legislation affecting the construction industry.  The updates are provided throughout the year by attorneys all over the … Continue Reading

Should Owners and Contractors Worry about Gifford’s Suit Against USGBC?

Posted in Case Law, Green Building
Initially filed as a class action suit in October 2010 against the USGBC, Henry Gifford’s lawsuit took a turn this week when he filed an amended complaint.  The original lawsuit alleged violations of the Sherman and Lanham Acts for “deceiving users” of the LEED rating system.  The lawsuit questioned whether "LEED buildings use less energy than conventionally-built buildings.” … Continue Reading